Who is the author of The Signal and the Noise?

The author of The Signal and the Noise is Nate Silver.

Technology & the Future

The Signal and the Noise Book Summary - The Signal and the Noise Book explained in key points

Listen to the Intro

00:00

The Signal and the Noise summary

Name: The Signal and the Noise
Rating: 4.2 (182 reviews)
Author: Nate Silver

Nate Silver

Why So Many Predictions Fail — but Some Don't

4.2 (182 ratings)

23 mins

Brief summary

The Signal and the Noise by Nate Silver explores the art of prediction and the challenges that come with it. Using real-world examples, he emphasizes the importance of gathering accurate information and separating signal from noise.

Topics

Mathematics Investments

Table of Contents

The Signal and the Noise
Summary of 12 key ideas

Audio & text in the Blinkist app

Key idea 1 of 12

What’s in it for me? Discover why more data doesn’t always equal better predictions.

“Prediction is very difficult, especially about the future”: so goes a quote often attributed to Danish physicist Niels Bohr.

Indeed, predictions are very difficult, as can be seen by looking at the dismal track records of experts’ predictions in diverse fields, such as meteorology, sports betting and politics. Even worse, experts tend to be fairly confident about the quality of their predictions despite historical data showing the opposite.

These blinks will outline the difficulties in predicting economic development and in locating the few pieces of key information – i.e., the signal – in the vast mass of data available – i.e., the noise.

Among other things, you’ll find out

why you could’ve made some outstanding profits based on who won the Super Bowl each year for three decades,
why a positive mammogram result can still only mean a 10 percent chance of having breast cancer and
why it’s natural that stock traders don’t care if a bubble forms in the market.

Economists are bad at both forecasting the economy and estimating the certainty of their forecasts.

Will you walk to work today or take the bus? Will you take an umbrella or not?

In our everyday lives, we make decisions based on predictions of what will happen in the future, like whether it will rain or shine.

But predictions are also common in the public realm: stock market analysts, meteorologists and sports commentators all make a living out of them.

One area where one might expect particularly good predictions is the economy. After all, it’s of crucial importance for individuals, companies and even nations, and there’s a wealth of data available: some companies track as many as four million economic indicators.

But despite these factors, economists have an atrocious track record in forecasting.

Consider the commonly predicted economic indicator, the gross domestic product (GDP).

The first problem with GDP predictions is that economists often make predictions like “Next year, GDP will increase by 2.7 percent.” In fact, they’ve derived this figure from a broad prediction interval that says something like “It is 90 percent likely that GDP growth will fall somewhere between 1.3 and 4.2 percent.” So an exact number as a prediction is misleading, as it gives a false sense of precision and security.

What’s worse, economists aren’t actually very good at coming up with prediction intervals either. If their 90 percent prediction intervals were roughly accurate, one would expect the actual GDP to only fall outside the prediction interval one out of ten times. However, a poll of professional forecasters shows that, since 1968, they’ve been wrong roughly half the time. Therefore, it seems that economists’ are not only poor predictors but also gravely overestimate their predictions’ certainty.

Besides GDP predictions, economists are also spectacularly bad at forecasting depressions. Consider that, in the 1990s, economists were only able to predict two out of the sixty depressions that had occurred worldwide one year ahead of time.

To put it kindly, economic predictions should be taken with at least a grain of salt.

Forecasting the economy is so difficult because it’s a complicated and dynamic system.

Why is predicting the economy so hard?

Quite simply, because a staggering amount of interwoven factors can influence it: a tsunami striking Taiwan can affect whether someone gets a job in Oklahoma.

Statistics-based forecasting alone is not enough – human analysis is still needed.

As stated in the previous blink, the economy is such a complex web of interrelated factors that causality is hard to define. This has lead many economists to try a purely statistical approach: instead of trying to understand what causes have which effects, they just look at huge swathes of data hoping to spot patterns.

Unfortunately, this approach is fraught with potential for errors because it is inevitable that some patterns will emerge due to coincidence alone.

Many experts failed to predict the 2008 collapse of the US housing bubble.

Let’s turn our gaze now to four forecasting failures in the run-up to the financial crisis of 2008, starting with those related to the housing bubble.

The first was the overly optimistic belief of homeowners, lenders, brokers and rating agencies that the meteoric rise of US house prices would continue indefinitely. They held this belief despite the fact that, historically, a meteoric rise in housing prices combined with record-low savings had always led to a crash.

Over-optimism in the US government and banks also spurred the financial crisis.

Continuing from the previous blink, let’s examine the two other forecasting failures that contributed to the financial crisis that started in 2008.

The third predictive failure happened at American financial institutions, which were so eager to chase after profits in the booming market that they leveraged themselves excessively with debt to make more investments.

Bayes’ theorem can help you update your beliefs rationally as new information arises.

As we’ve seen, forecasting is fraught with difficulties.

One key way of overcoming them when estimating probabilities is to adopt the so-called Bayesian approach, a theorem based on work by eighteenth century English minister Thomas Bayes. This approach provides a mathematical framework for updating one’s beliefs in a rational way as new information comes in.

Cautious, meticulous and diverse predictions tend to be better than brash ones.

To understand another key to making better forecasts, let’s take a look at what kind of people make the best predictions.

Beginning in 1987, a psychologist and political scientist by the name of Philip Tetlock began recording predictions on topics like politics and the economy made by a wide variety of experts.

Stock markets are hard to beat because they tend to be efficient.

One notoriously difficult phenomenon to predict is the short-term behavior of the stock market. Sure, in the long run, the average value of stocks tends to increase, but this information is of little use to most traders because they want to “beat the market.”

A desire that has proven to be spectacularly difficult to fulfill.

Stock market bubbles can be predicted by looking at stock prices and the P/E ratio.

Though the stock market usually tends to be efficient, this is not true when bubbles form, meaning situations where stocks are overvalued.

Though there is no foolproof way to predict a bubble, there are some telltale signs.

Simple climate models tend to work better than complicated ones.

Like the economy, the climate comprises a very complicated, interrelated system which is very difficult to model and make predictions about.

Even very sophisticated models that take into account countless factors, like El Nino cycles and sunspots, have failed spectacularly. For example, the International Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) based its 1990 prediction on such a complicated model, stating that, over the next hundred years, global temperatures would increase by between two and five degrees, with three degrees being the most likely result. But observations made over the next eleven years indicated this was completely wrong: the pace was only 1.5 degrees per century, below even the lowest end of their IPCC estimate.

It’s difficult but not impossible to predict and prevent terrorist attacks.

We’ve all heard of conspiracy theories relating to the 9/11 World Trade Center attacks. Some claim the attacks were so obviously predictable that the US government must have known about them in advance.

For example, in July 2001, there was a warning about heightened Al-Qaeda activity, and in August 2001, an Islamic fundamentalist was arrested due to his suspicious request to be allowed to practice flying on a Boeing 747 simulator. Also, previous terrorist plots of flying commercial jets into buildings had already been discovered.

Final Summary

The key message in this book:

Experts in many areas tend to make astonishingly poor predictions, yet voice far too much confidence in their accuracy. They all trawl through data looking for correlations but, in a world with rapidly increasing amounts of data, this is bound to result in coincidental patterns that will eventually backfire.

Want to see all full key ideas from The Signal and the Noise?

Key ideas in The Signal and the Noise

More knowledge in less time

Read or listen

Get the key ideas from nonfiction bestsellers in minutes, not hours.

Find your next read

Get book lists curated by experts and personalized recommendations.

Shortcasts ^New

We’ve teamed up with podcast creators to bring you key insights from podcasts.

What is The Signal and the Noise about?

The Signal and the Noise explains why so many expert predictions today fail spectacularly, and what statistical and probability tools are more up to the task of predicting real-world phenomena.

The Signal and the Noise Review

The Signal and the Noise (2012) by Nate Silver is an eye-opening exploration of the world of predictions. Here's why this book is definitely worth reading:

It offers a fascinating perspective on how and why predictions go wrong, revealing the pitfalls and limitations of forecasting.
Combining data analysis, storytelling, and real-world examples, Silver presents a compelling case for the importance of skepticism and probabilistic thinking.
The book's engaging narrative keeps readers hooked, effortlessly bridging complex concepts to create an enlightening and enjoyable reading experience.

Best quote from The Signal and the Noise

If political scientists couldnt predict the downfall of the Soviet Union – perhaps the most important event in the latter half of the twentieth century – then what exactly were they good for?

—Nate Silver

Who should read The Signal and the Noise?

Anyone whose job involves making predictions or forecasts
Anyone who wants to know why the economy is so difficult to predict

About the Author

Nate Silver is a statistician and writer who specializes in analyzing baseball and elections. He is perhaps most famous for correctly predicting the result of the 2008 US presidential election for 49 out of 50 states.

Categories with The Signal and the Noise

Technology & the Future

Book summaries like The Signal and the Noise

The Deficit Myth

Stephanie Kelton

Modern Monetary Theory and the Birth of the People's Economy

The Art of Risking Everything

The Rise of Finance and the Fall of American Business

17 min

4.1

The Myth of the Strong Leader

Archie Brown

Political Leadership in the Modern Age

How the Shipping Container Made the World Smaller and the World Economy Bigger

Journey Through Elon Musk’s Visionary Mind

Numbers Rule Your World

Kaiser Fung

The Hidden Influence of Probability and Statistics on Everything You Do

12 min

3.8

The Daily Stoic

Ryan Holiday & Stephen Hanselman

366 Meditations on Wisdom, Perseverance and the Art of Living

33 min

4.7

How to Think Like Socrates

Donald J. Robertson

Ancient Philosophy as a Way of Life in the Modern World

16 min

4.6

The Genius of Empathy

Judith Orloff

Practical Skills to Heal Your Sensitive Self, Your Relationships, and the World

15 min

3.9

Workstyle

Lizzie Penny and Alex Hirst

A revolution for wellbeing, productivity and society

21 Great Ways to Stop Procrastinating and Get More Done in Less Time

False Prophets, Free Markets, and the Fracture of Society

How The Quest For The Ultimate Learning Machine Will Remake Our World

21 min

4.4

Superforecasting

Philip E. Tetlock & Dan Gardner

The Art and Science of Prediction

18 min

3.8

The Great Mental Models, Volume 4

Nassim Nicholas Taleb

The Hidden Role of Chance in Life and the Markets

The War of the Presidents

The Path to Fulfilling and Sustainable Sexuality

21 min

4.4

The Score Takes Care of Itself

Bill Walsh

My Philosophy of Leadership

16 min

4.0

The ONE Thing

Gary Keller and Jay Papasan

The surprisingly simple truth behind extraordinary results

18 min

4.6

Artificial Intelligence & Generative AI for Beginners

Read People Like a Book

Patrick King

How to Analyze, Understand, and Predict People’s Emotions, Thoughts, Intentions, and Behaviors

The Foundations of Language, Writing, and Meaning

What Makes Human Intelligence Essential in the Age of the Algorithm

How We Know What’s Really True

26 min

4.3

Zero to One

Peter Thiel with Blake Masters

Notes on Startups, or How to Build The Future

Exploring Myths that Shape our Identity and Reality

Find Yourself by Not Following the Crowd

How a Decade of Financial Crises Changed the World

29 min

4.4

Ikigai

Hector Garcia Puigcerver & Francesc Miralles

The Japanese Secret to a Long and Happy Life

The Science of Conversation

How to Build Habit-Forming Products

21 min

4.6

A Short History of Nearly Everything

Bill Bryson

A journey into the most intriguing and intractable questions that science seeks to answer

38 min

4.5

The Anatomy of Anxiety

Ellen Vora

Understanding and Overcoming the Body's Fear Response

18 min

4.0

Think Like a Freak

Steven D. Levitt and Stephen J. Dubner

Find the unconvential yet brilliant ideas hidden in data

21 min

4.3

Unlock Your Leadership Story

Pat Wadors

How to Build Understanding and Motivate Teams Using Fables and Folktales

18 min

Simply Said

Jay Sullivan

Communicating Better at Work and Beyond

20 min

Blink

Malcolm Gladwell

The Power of Thinking Without Thinking

Time Management for Mortals

Say Less to Get More from Any Pitch or Presentation

Examine the Roots of Conflict and the Path to Justice in Palestine

Learn Anything and Everything (Starting with Shakespeare and Dickens)

The Rise of Addictive Technology and the Business of Keeping Us Hooked

19 min

4.2

The End of the World Is Just the Beginning

Peter Zeihan

Mapping the Collapse of Globalization

How Successful Companies Use Price to Profit and Grow

Successful Habits of Visionary Companies

19 min

4.4

Difficult Conversations Don't Have to Be Difficult

Jon Gordon & Amy P. Kelly

A Simple, Smart Way to Make Your Relationships and Team Better

19 min

3.9

Trump: The Art of the Deal

People ❤️ Blinkist

Sven O.

It's highly addictive to get core insights on personally relevant topics without repetition or triviality. Added to that the apps ability to suggest kindred interests opens up a foundation of knowledge.

Thi Viet Quynh N.

Great app. Good selection of book summaries you can read or listen to while commuting. Instead of scrolling through your social media news feed, this is a much better way to spend your spare time in my opinion.

Jonathan A.

Life changing. The concept of being able to grasp a book's main point in such a short time truly opens multiple opportunities to grow every area of your life at a faster rate.

Renee D.

Great app. Addicting. Perfect for wait times, morning coffee, evening before bed. Extremely well written, thorough, easy to use.