Why Your Next Hire Should Be a Designated Dissenter
Whether it’s by comments on the article you’re reading, product reviews, or persuasive colleagues, you’re being influenced by the crowd nearly every minute of the day. And sometimes, this might work to your advantage. Foursquare uses the wisdom of the crowd to serve up luscious lunch recommendations, and a product with a thousand 5-star Amazon reviews might just be the best thing on which you’ve ever spent your hard earned shekels.
Other times, however, outside influences can lead us all astray—especially at work.
“There are some cases where the crowd is not actually wise, and it can lead us to make worse decisions than we might make by ourselves,” behavioral economist, author, and Wharton professor Jonah Berger told Caitlin Schiller on the Simplify podcast.
“We’ve all been to meetings, for example, where you were thinking about doing B, but the first person says A, and the next person says A, and suddenly, you’re sitting there going, ‘Well, maybe I should go along with the group.’”
The tendency to conform is only natural because humans are wired to seek harmony. This also means, however, that a group of very intelligent individuals can lose track of their independent viewpoints with surprising alacrity, tumbling into a quagmire of unproductive, uncreative groupthink. Therein lies the negative side of influence.
“By not making room for independent voices,” Berger explained, “a group can end up making a worse decision.”
- 12 min reading time
- audio version available
And so, Berger decided to write a book about how to break free of the forces that draw us into their bad-decision orbit. In Invisible Influence, which was published earlier this year, Berger identifies a smart, surprising way to bust up groupthink, and you can hire one from inside your company today.
A designated dissenter is the person whose job it is in a meeting to skilfully disagree with the rest of the group, no matter what. If most of the people in the room are saying A, it’s the work of the designated dissenter to point out the holes in argument A and, instead, support B. By doing so, the designated dissenter not only makes sure their own voice gets heard, but also frees up everyone else to share their own opinion—even if it breaks form with the prevailing one.
“As long as everyone’s saying the same thing, well then it seems like a right answer and you should go along with the group,” Berger explained. “But if someone dissents, if there’s one dissenting opinion—even if they have a different opinion than yours—now it’s not a right-or-wrong answer, it’s a matter of opinion. And if it’s a matter of opinion, everyone feels much more comfortable sharing their own.”
Berger is quick to remind that influence is not inherently a negative thing, but a designated dissenter can be key in helping a group of good thinkers make great decisions.
Hear more about the designated dissenter and how to make the right decisions for yourself in Jonah Berger’s episode of Simplify.