Who Are You to Judge? summary

The Uncomfortable Necessity of Judgment

In Who Are You to Judge? by Erwin W. Lutzer, we are confronted with the uncomfortable necessity of judgment. The author begins by examining the modern disdain for judgment, noting that while society is quick to label any form of judgment as intolerant, it paradoxically thrives on a culture of critique and criticism. Lutzer emphasizes that judgment is an essential aspect of our lives, guiding our decisions and shaping our moral compass.

Lutzer delves into the Bible to illustrate the importance of righteous judgment. He points out that Jesus Himself made judgments, condemning the Pharisees' hypocrisy and calling for repentance. He encourages us to follow this example of discernment, distinguishing between the act of judging and the attitude of being judgmental.

Understanding the Difference Between Judging and Being Judgmental

In the next section of Who Are You to Judge? Lutzer draws a clear distinction between judging and being judgmental. He explains that while judging involves making evaluative decisions based on objective standards, being judgmental is characterized by a critical, condemning, and self-righteous attitude. Lutzer emphasizes that Christians are called to judge righteously, guided by the truth of God's word and motivated by love.

The author also addresses the misconceptions surrounding non-judgmentalism, pointing out that it is not a neutral position but rather a form of selective judgment. By refusing to judge certain behaviors or beliefs, we are, in fact, making a judgment about what is acceptable. Lutzer urges us to be discerning and not let the fear of being labeled judgmental prevent us from speaking out against sin and falsehood.

Applying Righteous Judgment in Our Lives

Continuing in Who Are You to Judge?, Lutzer discusses how we can apply righteous judgment in various areas of our lives. He explores the importance of discerning false teachers and doctrines, warning us of the subtle deceptions that can lead us astray. He also addresses the issue of moral relativism, stressing the need for objective moral standards in a society that increasingly rejects absolute truth.

Lutzer then takes a closer look at the role of judgment in our personal relationships. He encourages us to exercise discernment in choosing our friends and partners, emphasizing the significant impact these relationships can have on our spiritual journey. He also highlights the importance of self-judgment, urging us to examine our own lives and attitudes before passing judgment on others.

The Challenge of Speaking Truth in Love

In the final part of the book, Lutzer addresses the challenge of speaking truth in love. He acknowledges that while it is essential to stand firm in our convictions and confront sin, we must do so with a spirit of compassion and humility. Lutzer emphasizes that our goal should not be to condemn but to bring about repentance and restoration.

In conclusion, Who Are You to Judge? by Erwin W. Lutzer presents a compelling case for the necessity of righteous judgment in our lives. He challenges us to embrace this responsibility, discerning truth from falsehood and good from evil. Lutzer reminds us that while the world may reject our judgments, we are ultimately answerable to God, the ultimate judge, for the decisions we make.