Should We Eat Meat? Book Summary - Should We Eat Meat? Book explained in key points

Should We Eat Meat? summary

Name: Should We Eat Meat?
Rating: 3.4 (226 reviews)
Author: Vaclav Smil

Vaclav Smil

Evolution and Consequences of Modern Carnivory

Listen to the first key idea

Key idea 1 of 9

00:00

3.4 (226 ratings)

20 mins

9 key ideas

Audio & text

What is Should We Eat Meat? about?

Should We Eat Meat? (2013) helps you navigate the ethical dilemmas behind your hamburger with a broad and objective assessment of meat production and consumption. Should you stick to grass-fed beef or take up veganism to save the planet? These blinks will give you all the facts you need to make your own informed decision.

About the Author

Vaclav Smil is an interdisciplinary researcher combining the fields of energy, environmental studies, population change, food production, nutrition, public policy, technical innovation and risk assessment. He teaches at the University of Manitoba where he is a distinguished professor emeritus and was listed as one of Foreign Policy’s 2010 top 50 global thinkers.

Table of Contents

Key idea 1 of 9

High-quality meat proteins are essential for human development and health.

As a kid you probably learned about the food pyramid and the importance of carbohydrates and proteins for healthy growth and sustained energy. But did you know that some proteins are better than others? They’re called high-quality proteins and you get many of them by eating animal products.

In fact, humans evolved to eat other animals. For instance, a human’s digestive tract is clearly different from that of a herbivore because it has enzymes which developed specifically to digest meat.

But how does meat fit into our diets?

You can think about eating as the process of supplying yourself with the things necessary to sustain your metabolism and maintain, as well as grow, your body. To do that you need both macronutrients like carbohydrates, fats and protein, and micronutrients like vitamins. It just so happens that meat is an excellent source of both macro- and micronutrients, and proteins in particular.

For example, the high-quality protein in meat is essential for young children and serves a crucial function in brain growth. In addition, the energy per gram of fat in meat is more than double that of carbohydrates, clocking in at a whopping 39 kilojoules per gram as opposed to 17.3 for carbohydrates. Meat is also a superb source of iron, which is important because iron deficiency is a major global issue, affecting up to 1.6 billion worldwide. It can lead to impaired brain development and even maternal death.

But despite all the beneficial aspects of including meat in your diet there are some drawbacks. Meat production has a negative impact on the environment. That’s because the per-capita supply of meat available in many nations is higher than the average grown adult weight of 65 kilograms to 80 kilograms. This is an issue because the agricultural processes tied to meat production use a lot of energy and incur a variety of other costs. We’ll find out more about these in later blinks.

Meat played an important role in human evolution.

Have you ever noticed how prevalent meat eating is throughout history? It’s not a coincidence. In fact, meat served a crucial role in human evolution.

For instance, while historical meat consumption has fluctuated, purely vegetarian societies are few and far between. That’s because most cultures saw meat as an indicator of privilege and social status – a reasonable association, given that meat played an important function in the evolution of the human species, and especially our brains. All that protein and iron helped us grow bigger and better grey matter.

Increased meat production and consumption are symbols of the transition to modernity.

OK, so all this evolution happened millennia ago, but there has been a more recent evolution, and it all began in the nineteenth century.

Why?

In the twenty-first century, meat is produced on a huge scale.

For thousands of years domesticated meat production was done by either a farmer making use of grasslands in the country or by practitioners of mixed farming who integrated animal husbandry and crop production seamlessly into one another. But these methods are mostly a thing of the past.

Today, we have a systematic chain of meat production from breeding to raising to slaughtering to processing to distribution.

Large-scale meat production means large-scale problems.

Does the acronym CAFO ring any bells? It stands for Confined Animal Feeding Operations – the kind of production plants that churn out all that cheap meat to meet demand.

Factory-style farms in affluent countries began producing chickens raised on standardized feed after World War Two. Then the method was used to farm pigs, and spread from wealthy countries to Asia and Latin America. Today this method of animal production dominates everywhere but Africa. CAFOs even play a role in cattle raising, but almost exclusively in the United States and Canada.

Feeding animals in factory farms is big – and often inefficient – business.

It’s simple enough to see that more animals mean more feed. But did you know that fodder is the main reason that meat is so environmentally costly?

That’s because modern meat production in CAFOs and feedlots depends on a steady and cheap supply of compound feed, a standardized composition of carbohydrates enriched with proteins, the most common of which is corn, with protein being primarily supplied by oilseeds – soy in particular.

Feed production threatens soil, water and the atmosphere.

Consider the fact that a pig will eat about 300 kilograms of feed before it’s slaughtered. That means as much as 500 square meters is needed to grow the crops necessary to raise one pig! On top of that you need tons of nitrogen to fertilize the crops, and lots of energy to produce that nitrogen in turn.

As a result, large-scale meat production has dramatically reshaped land use. For instance, most people are unaware of the extent to which domesticated animals dominate the zoomass, the mass of all terrestrial vertebrates other than humans. Even in huge, heavily populated countries like the United States, animals raised for meat weigh as much as the human population of the entire nation! About a quarter of the ice-free continental surface of the Earth is used for livestock grazing, and one third of all arable land produces feed crops for them.

Meat alternatives all have limitations.

So, you’ve seen how meat production plays a role in global warming and deforestation. But what’s the alternative? Is not eating meat the only option? Maybe not.

If the number of vegetarians increased, that would help, but given the centrality of meat to our diet this wouldn’t be a wise move. For instance, a vegetarian diet can be as nutritious as one that includes meat but it requires more effort. That’s because vegetarians are hard pressed to ensure their diets include enough metals. Since one kilogram of vegetables isn’t nutritionally comparable to one kilogram of meat, it’s much easier to achieve a balanced diet by eating meat, especially for a young child.

The best solution is to continue producing meat but to do so rationally.

The truth is, current levels of meat production and consumption are not fixed. Although eating huge quantities of meat has become a mass phenomenon, it doesn’t have to remain one. We don’t even need to sacrifice our vital protein intake to do this.

That’s because there are other fantastic sources of protein beyond meat, like dairy products and eggs. While these can’t replace meat entirely, they can certainly put a dent in our consumption.

Want to see all full key ideas from Should We Eat Meat??

Key ideas in Should We Eat Meat?

More knowledge in less time

Read or listen

Get the key ideas from nonfiction bestsellers in minutes, not hours.

Find your next read

Get book lists curated by experts and personalized recommendations.

Shortcasts ^New

We’ve teamed up with podcast creators to bring you key insights from podcasts.

Who should read Should We Eat Meat?

Meat eaters and vegetarians alike
People looking for objective information about meat consumption and production
Anyone concerned about the Earth’s future

Categories with Should We Eat Meat?

Nature & the Environment Society & Culture

Books like Should We Eat Meat?

Earth for All

Sandrine Dixson-Decleve

A Survival Guide for Humanity

17 min

4.4

How the World Really Works

Vaclav Smil

The Science of Our Past, Present and Future

22 min

4.4

The Plant-Based Athlete

Matt Frazier and Robert Cheeke

A Game-Changing Approach to Peak Performance

Food, Free Will, and How the Food Giants Exploit Our Addictions

How the Modern World Was Made

Combine Paleo and Vegan to Stay Fit, Happy and Healthy for Life

The 12-step Guide to Science-based Nutrition for a Healthier and Longer Life

23 min

4.7

Decoding the World

Po Bronson and Arvind Gupta

A Roadmap for the Questioner

What Everyone Needs to Know

24 min

4.1

Foragers, Farmers, and Fossil Fuels

Ian Morris

How Human Values Evolve

22 min

4.0

What our members say

Sven O.

It's highly addictive to get core insights on personally relevant topics without repetition or triviality. Added to that the apps ability to suggest kindred interests opens up a foundation of knowledge.

Thi Viet Quynh N.

Great app. Good selection of book summaries you can read or listen to while commuting. Instead of scrolling through your social media news feed, this is a much better way to spend your spare time in my opinion.

Jonathan A.

Life changing. The concept of being able to grasp a book's main point in such a short time truly opens multiple opportunities to grow every area of your life at a faster rate.

Renee D.

Great app. Addicting. Perfect for wait times, morning coffee, evening before bed. Extremely well written, thorough, easy to use.

Start growing with Blinkist now

25 Million

Downloads on all platforms

4.7 Stars

Average ratings on iOS and Google Play

91%

Of Blinkist members create a better reading habit*

*Based on survey data from Blinkist customers

Powerful ideas from top nonfiction

Try Blinkist to get the key ideas from 5,500+ bestselling nonfiction titles and podcasts. Listen or read in just 15 minutes.

Start your free trial

Blink 3 of 8 - The 5 AM Club

by Robin Sharma

Should We Eat Meat? summary

Listen to the first key idea

What is Should We Eat Meat? about?

About the Author

High-quality meat proteins are essential for human development and health.

Meat played an important role in human evolution.

Increased meat production and consumption are symbols of the transition to modernity.

In the twenty-first century, meat is produced on a huge scale.

Large-scale meat production means large-scale problems.

Feeding animals in factory farms is big – and often inefficient – business.

Feed production threatens soil, water and the atmosphere.

Meat alternatives all have limitations.

The best solution is to continue producing meat but to do so rationally.

Key ideas in Should We Eat Meat?

High-quality meat proteins are essential for human development and health.

Meat played an important role in human evolution.

Increased meat production and consumption are symbols of the transition to modernity.

In the twenty-first century, meat is produced on a huge scale.

Large-scale meat production means large-scale problems.

Feeding animals in factory farms is big – and often inefficient – business.

Feed production threatens soil, water and the atmosphere.

Meat alternatives all have limitations.

The best solution is to continue producing meat but to do so rationally.

Who should read Should We Eat Meat?

Categories with Should We Eat Meat?

Books like Should We Eat Meat?

What our members say

Discover the Blinkist catalogue

Popular titles

Most popular categories

Trending Collections