close Facebook Twitter Instagram LinkedIn
10 mins

Fidelity vs Robinhood: Which Online Broker Is the Right for You?

Explore an in-depth comparison between Fidelity and Robinhood – two prominent players in the sector of personal finance apps. Grasp their unique value propositions, key features, and suitability, and make an informed decision rooted in your individual trading needs
by Chris Allmer | Nov 17 2023

Technology has transformed how we interact with money in the intricate dance of finance and stock trading. Mobile applications have allowed us to take control of our finances from our handheld devices, and now, more people are using apps to make informed financial decisions and investments. 

Out of a bustling ecosystem of financial apps, two names stand out in their popularity: Fidelity and Robinhood. Both apps have managed to carve niches for themselves in the tech-financial marketplace.

While both offer the promise of financial control and freedom, their approaches to users vary significantly, making each of them unique in its offerings. Fidelity, on its decades-long legacy in the economic domain, offers a comprehensive toolkit for financial management. On the other hand, Robinhood presents a more modernist, streamlined solution engineered for the new-age digital-native investor. 

Let’s embark on a journey of demystifying these financial tools and exploring how they fare against each other to help you map your financial journey more efficiently. 

Fidelity vs Robinhood – An Overview

As we venture into the fascinating realm of financial applications, two names frequently surface as strong contenders – Fidelity and Robinhood. Powerful in their offerings yet distinct approach, these platforms are carefully designed to cater to varying investment needs, thereby reformulating the landscape of modern investment.

Fidelity, an institution with a strong lineage in the finance industry, stands as a testament to a wholesome investment experience. Functioning as an all-round investment platform, Fidelity blends personalized advisory services, rigorous research tools, and diverse investment options into a cohesive whole. The central value proposition of Fidelity is its holistic investment approach.

From seasoned investors to individuals starting to explore financial markets, Fidelity offers a seamless solution. Its robustness stands out for intermediate to advanced investors, given the breadth of research tools they often require for complex financial decision-making. Moreover, the specialized advisory services bring home a personalized touch, and investing seems less of a daunting puzzle and more of a manageable set of choices.

Enter the realm of Robinhood, and a new dimension of financial-technological fusion unravels. Building itself upon accessibility, simplicity, and cost-effectiveness, Robinhood forges a low-resistance path for tech-centered, new-age investors.

Robinhood’s prime value is its simplicity of trading; it breaks down the often daunting walls of the financial markets into easily navigable pathways. Cost-effectiveness remains at the heart of Robinhood, with its unique zero-commission trades making it attractive for budget-conscious investors. As a digital-first platform, Robinhood is a user-friendly portal to the world of investments, primed for the mobile-savvy, self-directed investors who are comfortable steering their financial ship.


Fidelity vs Robinhood – The Facts

Moving forward, we’ll delve into a side-by-side comparison of Fidelity and Robinhood to paint a clear picture of how they stack up against each other. After all, each investor’s needs are unique, and having a comprehensive overview is paramount to making the right choice. The following table compares these two industry juggernauts across crucial features and capabilities such as types of investments, account minimums, commissions, and more. Let’s carefully navigate through these specifics.

Fidelity Robinhood
Types of investment Stocks, bonds, ETFs, Mutual Funds, Options Stocks, ETFs & Cryptocurrencies
Account Minimum $0 $0
Stock Trades Commission $0 $0
Options Contract Commission $0.65 $0
Short Sales Yes Yes
International Exchanges available 75 0
Fractional Share Trading Yes Yes
Fractional Dividend Reinvestments Yes Yes
Robo Advisory Yes No
Broker-assisted trade fee $32.95 N/A
Inactivity Fees No No


Fidelity: A Comprehensive Investment Platform

Nurturing a rich heritage and trusted lineage in the finance industry, Fidelity delivers a potent combination of wide-ranging investment options, personalized advisory services, and robust research tools. Established in 1946, Fidelity has grown and transformed into a formidable player in the online brokerage arena.

Key features of Fidelity include:

  • Diverse Investment Types: Fidelity offers many investment options, including stocks, bonds, ETFs, mutual funds, and opportunities. This diversification allows investors to build a versatile portfolio suited to their unique financial goals.
  • Advanced Research and Data tools: Armed with powerful research tools and real-time data streaming, Fidelity is a wellspring of information for savvy investors.
  • Personalized Investment Advisory Services: Fidelity provides access to dedicated advisors who provide expert assessments and guidance tailored to individual investment goals.
  • Accessible Learning Resources: Fidelity’s Learning Center is well-stacked with resources that empower investors to educate themselves, deepen their understanding, and make well-informed decisions.

Fidelity emerges as a leading choice due to its comprehensive approach to investment management. It integrates versatile investment choices, personalized advice, and thorough research capabilities under one roof, offering a holistic investment experience.

Fidelity is an impeccable fit for professional investors who yearn for detailed analyses, desire a broad spectrum of investment options, and value personalized advice. Furthermore, its Learning Center makes it an excellent choice for those who want to expand their investment knowledge. So, Fidelity could be your perfect investment partner if you’re a seasoned or aspiring investor looking for a comprehensive, trusted, and robust financial management platform.

At the heart of Fidelity’s offerings is financial education, a commitment to facilitating the journey of each investor from novice to expert. This commitment echoes the sentiments in the popular book, “Rich Dad’s Guide to Investing” by Robert Kiyosaki. Kiyosaki stresses the importance of education in successful investing, saying it’s not just about making money but understanding how it works. Just as this book provides steps to convert your earned income into passive and portfolio income, Fidelity provides the tools, resources, and expert guidance to put those steps into action, turning investment knowledge into tangible financial growth.


Robinhood: A Simplified Gateway to Investment

Robinhood is spearheading the revolution of simplified financial management, an app redesigning the concept of investing for modern, tech-savvy individuals. Founded on 2013 based on the ideas of accessibility, simplicity, and cost-effectiveness, Robinhood has successfully etched itself in the psyche of a new generation of investors.

Key features of Robinhood include:

  • User-friendly Interface: Robinhood stands out with its clean, intuitive interface. It was designed to make navigating the complexities of investing seamless, even for beginners.
  • Variety of Investment Channels: While its focus remains on stock and ETF trading, Robinhood also opens the door to cryptocurrency investing, a feature attracting many younger, tech-forward investors.
  • Commission-free Trades: The hallmark of Robinhood’s offering is cost-effectiveness. The platform charges no commissions on trades, which can significantly reduce the cost of investing, especially for those just getting started or working with smaller investment amounts.
  • Mobile App Availability: Robinhood’s robust platform is accessible across iOS and Android devices, making it a perfect companion for the mobile-savvy investor on the move.

The strength of Robinhood lies in its simplicity and streamlined user experience. It reduces the barriers typically associated with investing, making it an ideal platform for those wanting an easy, accessible, and affordable way to start their investment journey.

Robinhood perfectly matches self-directed, tech-savvy investors who have embraced the mobile-first world. Whether you’re a novice dipping your toes in the investment pool or a budget-conscious trader seeking a cost-effective platform, Robinhood has the tools and features to make your investment journey smooth and hassle-free. If simplicity, accessibility, and affordability top your list of investment platform requirements, Robinhood could be your ideal choice.

Echoing Robinhood’s core principle of simplicity, the Blinkist guide “Invest Like Warren Buffet” by James Altucher resonates with the same ethos. Navigating the complex world of investment becomes much more accessible when we follow the nuggets of wisdom from the Oracle of Omaha, Warren Buffet, which Altucher neatly curates in his guide. Just as the beauty of Robinhood lies in its ability to make trading uncomplicated for new-age investors, Altucher’s guide on Blinkist transforms the daunting task of investing into easily digestible insights and actionable advice. By marrying the simplicity of Robinhood with the easy approachability of investing strategies in “Invest Like Warren Buffet”, anyone can set foot on a rewarding investment journey.


Fidelity vs. Robinhood: Commissions & fees

Fidelity and Robinhood both champion affordable investing with their $0 commission fees for online stock and ETF trades. Furthermore, both firms do not charge an account maintenance fee unless you opt for the Robinhood Gold subscription, which incurs a $5 monthly fee.

Nevertheless, there are noteworthy distinctions between the two. With Fidelity, options trading involves a fee of $0.65 per contract, whereas Robinhood allows options trading sans any charges, making it a highly favorable platform for options traders.

Interestingly, while Fidelity levies no charges for account closure, Robinhood imposes a $75 fee. This means while exploring Robinhood, you need to keep in mind the expense attached to transferring your assets out of the platform if you decide to do so.

Beyond stocks and ETFs, Robinhood stands out with its provision for free cryptocurrency trading. It’s also important to note that neither broker charges fees for account opening, account inactivity or domestic wire transfers.

Margin trading is another area with notable differences. With Robinhood, the $5 Gold subscription includes $1,000 of margin. Any margin usage above this amount attracts a 7.75% interest charge. Fidelity, on the other hand, charges a margin interest of 10.0575% for a $10,000 balance and 9.075% at $100,000.

While both brokers generate earnings from interest on cash, margin interest, portfolio margining, and stock loan programs, payment for order flow is a revenue stream exclusive to Robinhood.

In conclusion, while both platforms excel in their domains, Fidelity often presents a more cost-efficient option, especially when considering its comprehensive platform capabilities. This complete value proposition played a significant role in Fidelity as the best online and low-cost broker for 2023.

Fidelity vs. Robinhood: Which One Is Best for Beginners?

Both Fidelity and Robinhood have unique features that make them suitable for beginners, but Fidelity takes the lead due to its flexible and learning-friendly offerings. Alongside conventional, do-it-yourself trading, Fidelity also provides automated investing accounts—an added convenience for beginners not found in Robinhood. While Robinhood is praised for its user-friendly interface, it operates exclusively as a self-directed trading platform. This means that beginners who are still traversing their way through the trading world and aren’t confident enough to trade independently might find it challenging. 

Consequently, Fidelity’s mix of learning resources, personalized guidance, and automated trading capabilities positions it as a more welcoming platform for those starting their investing journey.


Fidelity vs. Robinhood: Pros and Cons

As you embark on the journey of financial management and investing, settling on the right platform is crucial. Your choice hinges upon understanding and matching your specific needs to these platforms’ delivery. So, the question arises: which is perfect for your specific needs? And equally important, why might you consider avoiding a particular option? These are critical considerations, and through this comparative analysis, we aim to help you navigate these pertinent questions.


Perfect for… Avoid if…
Seasoned, experienced or aspiring investors seeking comprehensive financial solutions, diverse investment options, and personalized advice. Simplicity, a streamlined interface, and cost-effectiveness are your foremost priorities.


Perfect for… Avoid if…
Tech-savvy millennials and Gen-Z, self-directed investors who prefer a user-friendly, mobile-first, and affordable investment platform. You require research tools, personalized advisory services, or a more comprehensive range of investment options.

Fidelity vs. Robinhood: Our Final Recommendation

To wrap up, regarding the Fidelity vs Robinhood debate, it all depends on what you need from a trading and investment app.

While Fidelity brings a wealth of traditional financial expertise and comprehensive solutions to the table, Robinhood disrupts the conventional demands with its minimalist approach and budget-friendly model. One offers depth and diverse options, and the other offers simplicity and cost efficiency, thus catering to contrasting kinds of investors: experienced, research-driven investors would lean towards Fidelity, while the Millennials and Gen-Z investors seeking easy-to-navigate and economically efficient alternatives might find Robinhood to be their ideal choice.

As our detailed exploration of Fidelity and Robinhood concludes, it’s evident that expanding your financial knowledge is integral to smart investing. One powerful means to enrich this understanding is through insightful reads from industry gurus like Robert Kiyosaki. You can delve into his recommendations in this insightful collection of must-read books. From understanding the nuances of money management to decoding the secrets of profitable investment, these titles are filled with valuable insights.

Investing, after all, is not solely about making money but about understanding it – turning it from an elusive concept into a powerful tool. So, take a deep dive into Kiyosaki’s recommended readings and embark on a journey of continual learning. 

The financial landscape is not one-size-fits-all, so explore, experience, and empower your finances in the best way it serves you!

Start your free 7-day trial

Facebook Twitter Tumblr Instagram LinkedIn Flickr Email Print